What to build a treatment plant housing from: plastic, GRP, concrete or coated steel
The housing of a treatment plant is usually chosen by price and lead time, and a few years later it turns out that the housing decides whether the plant can be repaired, adapted to a new load, or has to be replaced entirely. Below we look at the loads acting on a housing, how four common materials cope with them, and which questions to ask before buying.
What destroys a treatment plant housing
Loads on the housing fall into three groups: chemical, mechanical and operational. Each material is weaker in one of them.
The chemical load is concentrated not in the water but above it. In oxygen-free zones of wastewater, bacteria reduce sulphates to hydrogen sulphide. The gas escapes into the air space under the cover, dissolves in condensate on the walls, and other bacteria oxidise it to sulphuric acid. That is why the wall above the water line and the roof deteriorate faster than the bottom. The mechanism is described in detail in the article on dissolved oxygen and odour: the more dead zones there are, the more aggressive the gas phase.
The mechanical load is soil pressure during backfilling, buoyancy at high groundwater, and impacts during loading, transport and lowering into the pit. An empty underground tank in wet soil behaves like a float: if it is not anchored or weighted, it will be pushed up in spring.
The operational load shows up later. After a few years the load on the site grows, the discharge point changes, and a new nozzle, baffle, sensor or airlift has to be added. A material that cannot be modified on site turns such a task into a housing replacement.
Plastic and GRP: low weight and limited modification
Polyethylene and polypropylene do not corrode in domestic wastewater, are light and suit serial products. Their weak point is stiffness. A plastic housing is sensitive to backfill quality: stones against the wall, backfill without layer-by-layer compaction or from one side deform it, and deformation disrupts baffles and overflows. At high groundwater a light housing needs anchoring. For small domestic plants installed correctly this is usually acceptable; the installation sequence is covered in the article on septic tank installation and start-up.
Glass-reinforced plastic (GRP) is stronger and also corrosion-resistant, so it is often used for tanks. Its quality depends heavily on the moulding process: layer thickness, impregnation, absence of voids. Impact damage can go unnoticed and show up as a crack later. Repair is possible but requires resin, reinforcing fabric, a dry prepared surface and experience; cutting a new nozzle into a finished housing is a separate job.
Concrete: compressive strength and a vulnerable gas zone
Cast-in-place or precast reinforced concrete works well in compression, resists flotation by its own mass and is familiar to builders. For large permanent structures it remains the main material.
The limitations of concrete come from the same sulphuric acid. It dissolves the cement paste above the water line: the surface softens, the aggregate is exposed, the cover over the reinforcement thins, and then the steel starts to corrode. The rate depends on hydrogen sulphide concentration and ventilation, so in inlet chambers, pumping stations and equalisation tanks uncoated concrete deteriorates faster than in aerated zones. Two more weak points are the tightness of joints between precast rings and the dependence of quality on site work. Changing the design of a finished concrete structure is possible, but it is construction work, not a modification.
Coated steel: repairability at the cost of discipline
A steel housing is strong, not brittle under impact, and can be modified by familiar methods: nozzles are welded in, baffles added, joints reinforced, pump guide rails and air pipes fixed. The housing can be fabricated and checked at the factory — geometry, welds, tightness — and delivered to site as a finished module. That is why steel is often used for process units: flotation units, reactors, equalisation tanks, chemical tanks.
The main weakness of steel is corrosion, and it is solved not by a brand of paint but by a protection system. Service life is determined by surface preparation (removal of rust and mill scale, degreasing, the right roughness), coating thickness and continuity, treatment of welds and edges, and curing before filling. A mistake at any of these steps creates a corrosion spot under the coating. An important consequence: after any welding on site, protection in that area must be restored with the same procedure, otherwise the repair creates a new weak point.
Stainless steel removes some of these issues, but not all. It is more expensive, and in an environment with chlorides and hydrogen sulphide, pitting corrosion is possible under deposits and in weld crevices, so the steel grade is chosen by wastewater composition. For large tanks, coated carbon steel is more common, while stainless steel is kept for parts that are hard to recoat: fasteners, guide rails, overflows, air distributors. Whichever option is chosen, the housing coating should be inspected every time the tank is emptied and touched up locally, without waiting for through-corrosion. Protective coatings for concrete and metal in the aggressive environment of treatment plants are a separate Solvia line, described on the SAPEX page.
Comparing materials by task
The ratings below are qualitative: actual figures depend on wall thickness, fabrication technology and site conditions.
| Criterion | Plastic | GRP | Concrete | Coated steel |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weight and transport | light | light | heavy, needs machinery | medium |
| Resistance in the gas zone | high | high | low without protection | depends on coating |
| Sensitivity to backfill and impacts | high | medium, hidden cracks | low | low |
| Flotation at high groundwater | needs anchoring | needs anchoring | resists by mass | needs anchoring or ballast |
| Repair on site | limited | needs special technology | construction work | welding and coating restoration |
| Modification after start-up | limited | limited | difficult | available |
| Typical application | small domestic plants | tanks, vessels | large permanent structures | process units, modules, pumping stations |
The table shows that there is no universal material. The material is chosen together with the process: a simple settling tank, an SBR reactor with aeration and airlifts, a pumping station with pumps on guide rails and a flotation unit place different demands on the housing.
What next
Before comparing offers, collect data about the site and how the facility will change. You will need: wastewater composition and volume, presence of dead zones and hydrogen sulphide risk, groundwater level and soil type, machinery access to the pit, and plans for load growth in the coming years. Ask the supplier what the housing is made of, how it is protected above the water line, how it is repaired on site and what happens if a new nozzle has to be cut in.
For industrial and commercial facilities, process units are collected in the industrial wastewater treatment section. For a private house, see the home septic tanks section; there, too, the choice starts with the number of residents and site conditions, not with the material.
