Home/Articles/Odour at the outlet stronger than above the treatment plant: where hydrogen sulfide leaves the water

Odour at the outlet stronger than above the treatment plant: where hydrogen sulfide leaves the water

October 20267 minSolvia process engineer

It happens that after a treatment plant has been tuned, the odour above the aerated tanks almost disappears, while at the outlet it stays just as strong or becomes more noticeable. This looks like a contradiction, but it usually has two explanations: hydrogen sulfide leaves the water not where it formed, and the section between the last tank and the discharge point works as a separate anaerobic reactor. To find the cause, the whole line has to be considered, not just the plant.

Where hydrogen sulfide forms and where it is released

Hydrogen sulfide dissolves in water, and while the water flows quietly in a closed pipe or stands in a manhole, a noticeable part of it stays in solution. The gas passes into the air where the contact surface between water and air increases sharply: at a drop, an overflow, a free-falling jet, in turbulent flow, when passing through gravel. This follows from Henry's law: a dissolved gas tends towards equilibrium with the air above the water, and the more intense the mixing, the faster that equilibrium is reached.

That is why the point where the odour is strongest often turns out to be a point of degassing rather than the source. The hydrogen sulfide may have formed in a manhole tens of metres before the outlet, travelled along the pipe in dissolved form and been released at the last drop.

pH matters too. Sulfide exists in water in several forms, and only one of them is volatile — molecular hydrogen sulfide. At a pH of about 7 this is roughly half of the dissolved sulfide, at pH 6 almost all of it, at pH 8 about a tenth. So the same amount of sulfide smells noticeably stronger in slightly acidic water than in slightly alkaline water.

Temperature works in the same direction: warm water holds less dissolved gas, and bacteria work faster in the warmth, so in summer the odour at the outlet is usually stronger than in winter. The typical pattern over the day is this: at night the flow is low and the water stands longer in the manholes, then the first morning discharge pushes out the stagnant water, and a large portion of hydrogen sulfide is released at the drop all at once.

The section after the last tank also works as a reactor

When on-site treatment plants are designed, the calculation usually covers the plant itself: volume, aeration, settling. Everything further on is seen as a simple water outlet. But after the last tank there are often inspection and holding manholes, overflow chambers, a long pipe, a gravel drain or old concrete chambers built at different times and without a common design.

Water leaves the aerated zone with some dissolved oxygen, but not much, while residual organic matter, suspended solids and carried-over sludge are present. In a quiet manhole the oxygen is consumed within hours. Sediment builds up on the bottom and biofilm grows on the walls. Then the same sequence follows as in an old septic tank: the oxygen runs out, the nitrate runs out, and sulfate reduction begins (bacteria reducing sulfate and producing sulfide). How the oxygen regime is linked to hydrogen sulfide is covered in detail in the article on dissolved oxygen and odour at a treatment plant.

The larger the volume of the manholes after the plant, the longer the water stands without oxygen. Several large chambers in a row can hold water longer than the biological stage itself. The residence time on this section can be estimated independently: add up the water volumes in all the manholes after the plant and divide by the daily flow. If the result is more than a few hours, and noticeably more during low-flow hours, the section has conditions for sulfate reduction even when the plant itself is working properly. A gravel drain is a separate case. While it is clean, water passes through it with access to air. When the pores silt up, oxygen-free zones form inside, and the drain, intended as polishing, becomes a source of hydrogen sulfide that escapes through the outlet, the hatches and the ground.

How to walk the line from the plant to the outlet

The diagnosis consists of following the path of the water point by point and assessing the same things at each one: is there oxygen, how much sediment, how does it smell with the hatch open. The order of the walk-through is summarised in the table.

PointWhat to checkWhat indicates a problem
Outlet of the last tankDissolved oxygen, clarity, floc carry-overOxygen near zero or turbid water with sludge
Manholes after the plantSediment level, black sludge, film, odour when openedA layer of sediment on the bottom, odour stronger than at the plant
PipelineSlope, backed-up sections, water travel timeStagnation, reverse slope, long travel at low flow
Gravel drainRate at which water drains, backing up, odour from hatchesWater drains more slowly and stands in inspection manholes
Discharge pointHeight of the drop, fall of the jet, ventilationFree fall of water inside an enclosed space

Dissolved oxygen is measured with a portable meter, and where it reads zero an ORP sensor (oxidation-reduction potential) is useful: strongly negative values confirm conditions for sulfate reduction. If the walk-through shows that the odour rises sharply after a particular manhole, the source has been found. The confirmation is simple: after that manhole is cleaned of sediment, the odour at the outlet should drop.

Checking with a gas detector before going down into a manhole is mandatory. At high concentrations hydrogen sulfide can no longer be smelled and is life-threatening.

What is changed on the section after the plant

The work follows the causes found during the walk-through, not a general recipe. If sediment builds up, the manholes are cleaned and regular pump-outs are introduced. If the water stands too long, the volume of stagnant chambers is reduced: some manholes are switched to flow-through operation, unnecessary drops are removed, the pipe slope is corrected. A silted gravel drain usually cannot be flushed — it is replaced, and the discharge method is chosen anew; the options are covered in the article on discharging treated water.

When the residence time cannot be shortened, an oxidant is supplied to the section. This may be light additional aeration of the last manhole or dosing of a nitrate-containing reagent: bacteria prefer nitrate to sulfate, and hydrogen sulfide stops forming. The reagent is fed by a dosing station, and the dose is set from measurements. If the odour escapes from an enclosed space, ventilation with treatment of the exhaust air is added, for example following the scheme of the SOLVIA AirECOX development. Ventilation without air treatment simply moves the odour to another point, so the exhaust is placed with the wind and neighbouring buildings in mind.

Increasing aeration in the main plant is pointless in this situation. If the hydrogen sulfide forms after the plant, extra air in the bioreactor will not remove the odour at the outlet, but it will consume electricity.

What next

If the odour at the outlet is stronger than above the tanks, start with a diagram of the section from the last tank to the discharge point. Mark all the manholes on it with their dimensions and depth, the length and slope of the pipe, whether there is a gravel drain, and the location and height of the drop at the outlet. Add the daily wastewater flow, the date the manholes were last cleaned and a description of where and at what time the odour is strongest. If possible, measure dissolved oxygen at the plant outlet and in each manhole. Such a diagram shows where the water stands without oxygen and where the hydrogen sulfide escapes into the air. Equipment for wastewater treatment stages is collected in the industrial wastewater treatment section.

Tags:WastewaterOperationEngineering